1. BACKSTG
  2. Guides
  3. How to manage mix versions and comments
Mixing and feedback

How to manage mix versions and comments

A mix reaches five versions and ten comments in a chat. Half the problems are not the mix: nobody knows which version the commenter heard and which point they mean.

On this page
  1. One version is the current one
  2. Name the versions, not the hope
  3. Feedback on the exact minute
  4. One round at a time
  5. Close the job
  6. A message that works
  7. Frequently asked questions

In short

  • One version is the current one, the others stay but are not played.
  • Feedback is written on the exact minute, not in words.
  • Each round of changes is closed before another is opened.

A client writes "the bass is too loud" and you cannot tell whether they mean yesterday's version or this morning's. With versions and comments in order, that question disappears.

One version is the current one

Old versions are kept, but nobody plays them any more. Whoever replies must always know which one they are talking about.

VersionStatus
v1Archived
v2Archived
v3Current, the one to play

Name the versions, not the hope

Use a number and a date: "Late Night v3, 14 Nov". If only a detail changes, it is still a new version.

Feedback on the exact minute

"The vocal is low" is not enough. "At 1:12 the vocal is covered by the synth" is fixed in a minute. Writing on the exact point, see how to give and ask for feedback on a mix, removes the guesswork.

One round at a time

  1. The client listens to the current version and writes all feedback at once.
  2. You read, group the identical requests and answer the ones you will not do.
  3. You make the changes and upload the new version.
  4. The client listens only to that one and confirms or opens the next round.

Feedback that arrives in pieces, one a day, derails the work: the mix moves with every message.

Close the job

When the client approves, mark that version as final and deliver the final files. For how to send the mix see how to send a mix to a client without WeTransfer, and for keeping demos and versions in order how to organise demos and versions.

A message that works

When you upload a new version, write two lines: what you changed and what you ask.

Hi Marta, I uploaded v3 of "Late Night". I lowered the bass at 0:45 and raised the vocal in the chorus. Listen and write the minute of anything that is off, one round by Friday.

The client knows what to listen for, you know when to close. Feedback that arrives after the round goes into the next round.

Frequently asked questions

How many versions of a mix are normal?

It depends on the job. What matters is that only one is current and each round of changes closes before the next.

How do I write useful feedback on a mix?

Give the exact minute and what you would change: 'at 1:12 the vocal is covered by the synth'.

Can comments stay tied to the version?

Yes: on BACKSTG comments stay on the minute of the song and new versions are uploaded into the same song.