1. BACKSTG
  2. Guides
  3. How to give and get feedback on a mix
Mixing and feedback

How to give and get feedback on a mix

Vague feedback costs an extra revision. Precise feedback, tied to a point in the track, turns into a five-minute fix. Here is how to get the second kind.

On this page
  1. Write the minute and second
  2. Give every note three parts
  3. Listen properly before writing
  4. Send all notes in one batch
  5. For engineers: how to get useful notes
  6. Pick the right format for notes
  7. FAQ

In short

  • Every note says where (minute and second), what (the element) and which direction.
  • Listen on two systems, at moderate volume, against a level-matched reference.
  • Send all notes for a revision in one batch, most important first.

"Something's missing" is a real feeling, but it doesn't tell the engineer where to work. Notes need a simple structure.

Write the minute and second

A timestamp removes the ambiguity: the engineer jumps to that point and hears what you heard. Write as you listen, pausing the player: at the end you'd only remember the last thirty seconds.

Music / Winter Sea
Winter SeaMixed by Harbor Studio · 88 BPMv2v3
MML
1:20 / 3:48Note written by pausing the player
  • MMaya0:58The chorus has the same energy as the verse
  • MMaya1:20In the car the bass disappears under the kick
  • LLeo3:05The vocal reverb hangs too long after the last word
Every note has its spot on the waveform: the engineer works through them in order.

Give every note three parts

Where, what, which direction: the minute and second or the section, the element involved, a verb with an amount. You don't need technical terms: the engineer does the translating.

1:20Where: minute and second, guitarWhat: the element, a little quieterWhich direction, and how much
A note in three parts: the engineer knows where to go and what to do.
Vague noteUsable note
Something's missing0:58, the chorus doesn't lift from the verse: push the guitars
Make it warmerVocal harsh on the S sounds: less top end on the vocal
I can't hear the bass1:20, in the car the bass disappears under the kick

Listen properly before writing

A note that holds on two different systems is almost always right.

Send all notes in one batch

A revision is one list, agreed within the band first: five messages over two days waste everyone's time. Put the notes that change the song on top, then the details.

For engineers: how to get useful notes

Engineers can ask for better notes, with every delivery.

  1. Say what changed

    One line against the last version.

  2. Ask for timestamps

    With an example.

  3. Set a deadline

    And the revisions left.

  4. Reply to every note

    Even just "done".

For notes: pause and write the time, the element and what you'd change (e.g. 1:12, guitar covers the vocal). Everything in one message by Thursday.

Pick the right format for notes

For revisions, a written comment on a point in the track wins.

FormatWorks forLimit
Timestamped commentRevisionsNeeds a suitable player
Voice noteQuick ideasCan't be searched
CallDirectionLeaves no trace

FAQ

How do I write a timestamp in mix notes?

Minutes:seconds, like 1:12. For a section, start and end: 1:12 to 1:40.

What if I can't describe what I don't like?

Point to the moment and a comparison: "like this reference at 0:45". A reference says more than an adjective.

How many mix revisions are normal?

It depends on your agreement with the engineer: settle it before starting. More in our guide to online mixing and mastering.