On this page
In short
- Every note says where (minute and second), what (the element) and which direction.
- Listen on two systems, at moderate volume, against a level-matched reference.
- Send all notes for a revision in one batch, most important first.
"Something's missing" is a real feeling, but it doesn't tell the engineer where to work. Notes need a simple structure.
Write the minute and second
A timestamp removes the ambiguity: the engineer jumps to that point and hears what you heard. Write as you listen, pausing the player: at the end you'd only remember the last thirty seconds.
- MMaya0:58The chorus has the same energy as the verse
- MMaya1:20In the car the bass disappears under the kick
- LLeo3:05The vocal reverb hangs too long after the last word
Give every note three parts
Where, what, which direction: the minute and second or the section, the element involved, a verb with an amount. You don't need technical terms: the engineer does the translating.
1:20Where: minute and second, guitarWhat: the element, a little quieterWhich direction, and how much| Vague note | Usable note |
|---|---|
| Something's missing | 0:58, the chorus doesn't lift from the verse: push the guitars |
| Make it warmer | Vocal harsh on the S sounds: less top end on the vocal |
| I can't hear the bass | 1:20, in the car the bass disappears under the kick |
Listen properly before writing
A note that holds on two different systems is almost always right.
Send all notes in one batch
A revision is one list, agreed within the band first: five messages over two days waste everyone's time. Put the notes that change the song on top, then the details.
For engineers: how to get useful notes
Engineers can ask for better notes, with every delivery.
- Say what changed
One line against the last version.
- Ask for timestamps
With an example.
- Set a deadline
And the revisions left.
- Reply to every note
Even just "done".
For notes: pause and write the time, the element and what you'd change (e.g. 1:12, guitar covers the vocal). Everything in one message by Thursday.
Pick the right format for notes
For revisions, a written comment on a point in the track wins.
| Format | Works for | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Timestamped comment | Revisions | Needs a suitable player |
| Voice note | Quick ideas | Can't be searched |
| Call | Direction | Leaves no trace |
FAQ
How do I write a timestamp in mix notes?
Minutes:seconds, like 1:12. For a section, start and end: 1:12 to 1:40.
What if I can't describe what I don't like?
Point to the moment and a comparison: "like this reference at 0:45". A reference says more than an adjective.
How many mix revisions are normal?
It depends on your agreement with the engineer: settle it before starting. More in our guide to online mixing and mastering.